Provenance Provenance

The movement of the Emwin Arre, objects of tradition or historical relevance, can be traced from their production in the Benin Kingdom to the collections that hold them today. Their biographies unfold through a chain of events, tracing their movement from makers through the looting of 1897, subsequent sales, gifts and museum acquisitions, and, more recently, restitution. Where museum records are silent or incomplete, available evidence and contexts help reconstruct these histories, distinguishing what is documented from what is inferred and placing each event within the wider histories that shaped the global dispersal of Benin heritage.

Contact with Europeans before 1897

Benin-Portuguese Ivories
Diplomatic Gifts
Benin Artefacts Acquired by Museums before 1897

February 1897 and after: invasion and looting

The Role of German and British Traders and Shipping Companies
Prize, Trophies and Loot
Looting of the Ọba's Palace
Looting of the Iy'Ọba Palace
Looting of the Benin Ama-Ẹrọnmwọn (Brass Relief Plaques)
Looting of the Aken'ni Elao and of the Ivory Artefacts
Looting of the Wooden Objects in Benin City, 1897-1899
Destruction of the Palatial Compound and Surroundings, February 1897
Objects Possibly Looted or Appropriated after the Colonial Expedition (Until 1899)
Looting and Extraction of Benin Objects during British colonial military campaigns in Nigeria
Iconoclasm and the Extraction of Cultural Artefacts after 1899
The Undocumented Distribution of Looted Materials

Distribution and the early market (1897-1930s)

Trophy-Making: Added Plaques, Inscriptions and Mounts
The Market for Benin “Spoils” and Early Museum Acquisitions in Great Britain (1897–1930s)
The Market for Ethnographica, Benin Artefacts, and Early Museum Acquisitions in Germany (1897–1930s)
The Development of an Art Market for the Benin Pieces: The Case of France

Benin after 1897: new commissions, production and local market

Productions by Benin Craftsmen after February 1897 and Commissioned Artefacts
Production of Wooden Uhunmwu-Elao in the 20th Century in Benin City
Production of Obele in Southern Nigeria
Objects Selected and Produced for the Wembley British Empire Exhibition

Collections and markets in the 20th century

The Market for Benin Objects in Benin City and Nigeria in the 20th Century
Benin Objects in Private Collections
Museum Types and Benin Collections
The Sale and Exchange of Duplicates
American Public Collections: Scientific Specimens and the Art Museum
Cases and Potential Cases of Looted Jewish Collections
Damage, Destruction and Loss during the Second World War
The Development of the American Market for Benin Pieces (1950s–1970s)
The Case of Nigerian Public Collections - Buying Back Benin Heritage
Museum Acquisitions on the Global Art Market since the 1960s

Reading the objects today: alteration, attribution and uncertainty

The Manipulation and Alteration of Objects by Collectors and Dealers
Interventions: Dealer, Collector and Museum Inventory Numbers and Labels
Fragments and Broken Objects
Conservation Treatments, Scientific Research and Sampling in the Museum Settings
European Copies, Pieces ‘in the Style’ of Benin Objects and European Objects in Benin
Lower Niger Bronzes & Objects from Regions near Benin
Looted? Inconclusive Evidence
High Probability of Unrecorded Provenance

Return and restitution

The Reinstatement of Cultural Practices and Early Requests for Returns
Post-Independence Appeals for Returns
Activism and the Restitution and Call for Return of Emwin Arre in the 20th and 21st Centuries
21st-Century Developments: Benin. Kings and Rituals and the Development of the Benin Dialogue Group
Dutch Colonial Collections Policy and Development of the Committee Imogen
Joint Declaration on the Return of Benin Bronzes and Bilateral Museum
Gazette Declaring the Ọba of Benin’s Ownership of Benin Royal Artefacts

Use and preservation

Reign of Ọba Ẹsigie
Reign of Ọba Ovonramwẹ
Productions of the Igbesamwan guild in Benin City
Productions of the Igun-Ẹrọnmwọn guild
Productions of the Igun-Ematon guild
Productions of the Emada
Productions of the Enisẹn
Productions of Imakhe (potters)
Productions of the Isekpokin guild
Productions of the Owina (royal court weavers guild)
Display and preservation of the Ama-Ẹrọnmwọn in Benin City
Use and preservation of Abokpo in Benin
Use and preservation of Ada in Benin
Use and preservation of Aga in Benin City
Use and preservation of Agba in Benin
Use and preservation of Agbada in Benin
Use and preservation of Ahianmwẹ-Ọrọ in Benin.
Use and preservation of Aken'ni Elao in Benin
Use and preservation of Akhẹ in Benin
Use and preservation of Akhẹ Osun in Benin
Use and preservation of Akohẹn/Oko in Benin City
Use and preservation of Akuọghọ in Benin
Use and preservation of Anwa/Akpoka in Benin
Use and preservation of aro ododua in Benin
Use and preservation of asa in Benin
Use and preservation of asigbe in Benin
Use and preservation of asoro in Benin
Use and preservation of bronze okpia in Benin
Use and preservation of Ebẹn in Benin
Use and preservation of Ẹgba in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ẹgogo in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ehiamwen Ivin in Benin
Use and preservation of Ẹkpẹtin in Benin
Use and preservation of Ẹkpoki in Benin
Use and preservation of Elubasẹ/Isevbere
Use and preservation of Emwiegbe in Benin
Use and preservation of Ẹrhẹ in Benin
Use and preservation of Ẹrhu in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ẹroro in Benin
Use and preservation of Ewua in Benin City
Use and preservation of horns in Benin
Use and preservation of horse rider figures in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ibierugha in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ido in Benin
Use and preservation of Ighẹghan in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ikẹgobọ in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ikoro in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ikpakohen in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ikpin in Benin
Use and preservation of Isẹ in Benin
Use and preservation of Isẹ vbe ẹigho in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ivbiotọ in Benin City
Use and preservation of Okhuo figures in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ọkporhu and Iyeọkhọkhọ in Benin
Use and preservation of Ọrhiẹvbẹ in Benin
Use and preservation of Oroka in Benin City
Use and preservation of Osogan in Benin
Use and preservation of Oyiya in Benin
Use and preservation of pendant plaques in Benin
Use and preservation of staffs of office in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ufere in Benin
Use and preservation of Ugbẹkun in Benin
Use and preservation of Ugbudian in Benin
Use and preservation of Ugbugbe in Benin
Use and preservation of Ughegbe in Benin City
Use and preservation of Uhẹnhẹn/Ekuyẹ in Benin
Use and preservation of Uhunmwu elao ọghe Iy’ọba on altars in Benin
Use and preservation of Uhunmwu-Ẹkuẹ in Benin
Use and preservation of Uhunmwu-Elao on altars in Benin
Use and preservation of Ukhurhẹ in Benin City
Use and preservation of Uko Ẹkhaẹ in Benin City
Use and preservation of Uko in Benin City
Use and preservation of Ukpu in Benin City
Use and preservation of Umozo/Ọhọ in Benin
Use and preservation of Urhotọ in Benin
Use and preservation of Urhukpa-Ẹvbi in Benin City
Use and preservation of Uru in Benin
Use and preservation of Urua in Benin
Use and preservation of Uzokpo in Benin
Use of Aghẹn in Benin
Use of Akhiọn/Ukoko in Benin City
Use of Aza in Benin
Use of Azuwa in Benin
Use of Ẹkpẹde in Benin
Use of Ema in Benin
Use of Ẹzuzu in Benin City
Use of Idẹnrhẹn in Benin
Use of Ifẹnmwẹ in Benin
Use of Isanrẹn in Benin City
Use of Ovazẹ in Benin
Use of Uhanbọ in Benin
Use of Uhunmwu-Ewawa in Benin
Use of Ukpọn during military festivals
Sensitive content

Sensitive Content Digital Benin includes colonial material that may contain inaccurate, derogatory or harmful language relating to African and African diasporic communities. Such language may appear in catalogue records, transcriptions, and book, exhibition or museum titles. We recognize that this material may cause distress. Sensitive-content warnings are being implemented across the collection, but this process is ongoing. The language does not reflect Digital Benin’s views; we take an anti-colonial and anti-racist position and are committed to centring the humanity of historically marginalised communities.

Read more about our approach