Digital Benin was developed between 2020 and 2026 through an international and interdisciplinary collaboration, bringing together researchers, developers, designers and Edo scholars and knowledge holders across Nigeria, Europe, the US and beyond. Hosted by MARKK and supported by the Ernst von Siemens Kunststiftung, Gerda Henkel Foundation and Mellon Foundation, the project connected diverse forms of knowledge and perspectives to shape research, documentation, data, design and technical infrastructure, deepening understanding of histories and continuing cultural lives of Benin heritage.
The Photography Archive
The Digital Benin photography archive brings together more than 5,015 photographs from colonial and later collections relating to the Benin Kingdom. The photographs document people, places, objects and events connected to the history of the Kingdom and its relationships with European colonial actors.
Digital Benin received more than 30,000 photographs from institutions and collections around the world. Of these, 5,015 photographs fell within the scope of the project and were incorporated into the photography archive. The archive brings together images that had previously been dispersed across museum, library and archival collections, including photographs documenting the Benin Royal Palace and surrounding communities, the 1897 British invasion and its aftermath, the removal and circulation of Benin objects, colonial encounters, people and places, and the subsequent histories of the objects in European and North American collections.
The photographs are not treated simply as illustrations of historical events. They are historical sources in their own right. They provide evidence about people, places, objects, architectural spaces, material culture and colonial encounters, while also reflecting the circumstances and power relationships under which the photographs were produced.
This distinction is important because photographs are not neutral records of the situations they depict. A photograph selects what is visible within its frame and reflects the circumstances, intentions and technologies through which it was produced. In colonial contexts, the camera was part of broader systems of knowledge production and unequal relations of power. The resulting image therefore documents both what appears before the camera and the conditions under which it was made ( Odumosu 2020; Krabbe Meyer and Odumosu 2020).
The archive consequently raises particular questions about how colonial photographs should be described, contextualised and made accessible. Many of the images were produced by British and other European colonial actors and depict people, cultural practices and places through a colonial gaze. Some document the desecration of Benin customs and looting associated with the 1897 invasion; others depict royal and community spaces, including private shrines and altars, or show Benin people and cultural materials after their removal from their original contexts (Odumosu 2024).
The photographs can therefore provide important evidence for historical and provenance research while simultaneously raising questions about consent, cultural authority, privacy, sacred knowledge and the continued circulation of colonial representations.
Approaching Colonial Photographs with Care
The initial response to these questions was the establishment of a working document, Approaching Colonial Photographs with Care. The document was developed in response to the need for an approach to photographic material that recognised both its historical research value and the cultural implications of making it digitally accessible.
The working document was developed with experts in Benin City and the Diaspora and worked with Dr. Temi Odumosu, whose initial text for Digital Benin established an important conceptual framework for thinking about the photographs. The 2024 text was commissioned by Digital Benin to develop recommendations and initial ethical guidelines for handling and sharing colonial photographs on the platform (Odumosu 2024). Rather than proposing a universal set of rules for photographic access, the text created an ethical pause around the question of what is at stake when colonial photographs are brought together and recirculated in a digital environment.
Odumosu's framework emphasises that photographs are layered forms of storytelling. They can provide information about people, clothing, objects, architecture, locations and social interactions, while simultaneously obscuring information and shaping how viewers understand what they see. In a colonial setting, the image is only one part of a larger situation: it is a selected view produced through a particular technological and social relationship (Odumosu 2024).
The framework also draws attention to the uncertainty surrounding consent. For many colonial photographs, it is impossible to establish whether those represented understood how their images would be used, where they would circulate or whether they consented to their reproduction and preservation. This uncertainty becomes particularly significant when photographs are digitised and made available to a global audience.
The working group therefore approached the photographs not only as historical documents but also as objects with their own histories. Questions of consent, cultural authority, privacy, sacredness and the circumstances under which an image was produced became part of the process of determining how the archive should be presented.
The original framework identified three interconnected areas of work:
community-based evaluation of the photographic corpus;
critical approaches to cataloguing and description; and
an ethical guidance resource for access and engagement.
The subsequent workshops and review process developed these ideas into practical parameters for the Digital Benin archive (Odumosu 2024).
Community Review and Workshops
Of the more than 5,015 photographs that fell within the scope of the project, 900 were selected for detailed review with community participants in Benin City.
The review process involved elders, chiefs, scholars and other knowledge holders. Rather than asking participants simply to determine whether individual photographs were historically useful, the workshops considered the cultural circumstances in which images had been made and the implications of making them accessible through a public digital platform.
The workshops created a space in which the photographs could be considered from perspectives that were not necessarily represented in the original museum or archival descriptions. Participants were able to identify cultural, historical and ritual contexts that could not be established through institutional metadata alone.
The discussions considered what kinds of images should be publicly accessible, which images required additional contextualisation or warnings, which should be subject to restricted access, and which should not be made publicly available at all.
Particular attention was given to images depicting ancestors, human remains, burial sites, altars, shrines and sacred spaces. Participants also considered images involving nudity, secluded ceremonies and other subjects for which cultural context affects the conditions under which an image can appropriately be viewed.
The workshops therefore did not result in a single rule that could be applied uniformly to the entire archive. Instead, they established a set of guiding parameters that recognise different degrees of cultural sensitivity and different forms of access.
This process was important because it shifted decisions about photographic access from being solely an institutional or technical matter to one informed by community knowledge and cultural considerations. The resulting parameters provide a framework through which the archive can distinguish between photographs that can be openly shared and photographs whose circulation requires additional forms of care.
The workshop process also addressed questions of description and metadata. Colonial photographic collections often arrive with inherited titles, descriptions and classifications that reflect the circumstances and assumptions of the institutions that created or subsequently catalogued them. Critical approaches to metadata therefore form an important part of responsible digital access ( Krabbe Meyer and Odumosu 2020).
From Community Consultation to Access Parameters
The workshop process resulted in six principal areas of consideration. These parameters inform the access level applied to photographs within the archive.
Photographs that depict practices or subjects considered taboo under Edo cultural customs and rules are not made publicly accessible.
These images are understood as material that should not be placed into unrestricted digital circulation. The restriction recognises that digitisation can make images available in ways that were not possible when they were held in physical collections and that increased visibility does not necessarily correspond to appropriate access.
Access level: No public access.
Photographs depicting human remains and burial sites are subject to restricted access.
These images are accompanied by content advisories and contextual information intended to limit unexpected exposure and provide information about the cultural significance of the material.
The restriction recognises that images of human remains and burial places can have significance beyond their value as historical documentation and therefore require particular care in their presentation.
Access level: Restricted access.
Photographs depicting altars, shrines and sacred sites are subject to a higher level of restriction.
These images are not displayed publicly. Researchers may request access through a written application explaining the purpose of their research.
This distinction recognises that sacred spaces and objects can be subject to cultural rules governing who may see, document or circulate information about them. The fact that an image exists within a museum or archival collection does not, in itself, establish that it should be made openly accessible online.
Access level: Highly restricted access.
Photographs depicting nudity are subject to restricted access.
Where such images are made available, content advisories and limited visibility are used, together with contextual information. The intention is to avoid unnecessary exposure while preserving access to photographs that may have historical or research significance.
The approach recognises the dignity of the people represented and the different circumstances under which colonial photographs of bodies were produced and subsequently circulated.
Access level: Restricted access.
Photographs documenting public ceremonies and rites of passage can be made publicly accessible, while images depicting secluded rituals are subject to additional restrictions.
The distinction is based on the cultural context of the activity represented. Public ceremonies may form part of the historical record intended for wider circulation, while secluded royal ceremonies may be governed by different expectations concerning access and visibility.
Where access to secluded royal ceremonies is appropriate for research purposes, researchers may request access through a written application.
Access level: Public access, with restrictions for secluded rituals.
Photographs produced through colonial encounters or under circumstances involving coercion, violence or unequal power relationships require cultural-sensitivity measures.
These photographs may remain accessible because of their historical and evidentiary significance, particularly where they document the 1897 invasion, the removal of objects, colonial encounters or the subsequent history of Benin cultural heritage.
However, access is accompanied by cultural-sensitivity labels, content advisories and, where appropriate, filters that limit visibility. The purpose is not to remove historically significant material solely because it is difficult, but to provide context for its viewing and acknowledge the circumstances under which it was produced (Odumosu 2024).
Access level: Access with cultural-sensitivity measures.
Access Levels
The parameters developed through the workshops were translated into five levels of access within the photography archive.
The photograph is available to view online without restrictions.
This level is used where the photograph does not fall within the categories requiring additional restrictions.
The photograph is available to view online, but a warning is provided before viewing to indicate potentially sensitive content.
The advisory provides an opportunity for users to understand the nature of the material before choosing to view it.
The photograph is not immediately visible and requires an additional action before it can be viewed, such as acknowledging a content advisory.
This level is used for material that remains available for public research but requires additional care in its presentation.
The photograph is not displayed publicly. Access is available only for approved research purposes through a written application.
This level is used particularly for photographs of altars, shrines, sacred sites and other material for which unrestricted circulation is considered inappropriate.
The photograph is not made available online because its content is considered to contravene Edo cultural customs or rules.
This represents the highest level of restriction and reflects the principle that not all cultural material should be made publicly accessible simply because it has been digitised or held within an institutional collection.
Access as a Form of Curation
The access parameters represent more than a technical system for controlling visibility. They form part of the curatorial approach to the photography archive.
Digitisation can substantially change the conditions under which historical photographs circulate. An image that was previously held in a physical archive, accessible only to a limited number of researchers, can become available to a global audience through a digital platform. This change in scale creates new responsibilities concerning how images are described, contextualised and shared.
For Digital Benin, this means that access cannot be determined solely by whether an institution has made an image available or whether copyright permits its publication. The cultural circumstances surrounding the image are also relevant.
The parameters therefore introduce distinctions between different kinds of access. Public availability is not treated as the default outcome for every photograph, and restriction is not understood simply as the removal of historical evidence. Instead, different access levels provide ways of preserving the research value of the archive while recognising cultural authority and the circumstances under which particular images should be encountered.
This approach also acknowledges that existing metadata surrounding colonial photographs may itself contain problematic terminology. Museum catalogue records, archival descriptions, book titles, exhibition titles and other historical sources can contain derogatory, racist or otherwise harmful language. Such descriptions may be retained where necessary to document the historical record, but they do not represent the terminology or views of Digital Benin. Critical cataloguing can therefore become a means of identifying and contextualising inherited descriptive practices rather than reproducing them uncritically ( Krabbe Meyer and Odumosu 2020).
The archive combines access decisions with contextualisation and critical cataloguing. The aim is to make the photographic corpus useful for historical research while avoiding the assumption that institutional descriptions or colonial categories constitute neutral accounts of the people, objects and places represented.
Photograph-Level Explanations
The access framework is also communicated at the level of individual photographs. Where a photograph is restricted, users are provided with an explanation of the relevant parameter and the reason for the access condition.
For photographs that contravene Edo cultural customs, the archive explains that the photograph has been reviewed through community consultation and, in accordance with the guiding parameters developed by community participants, is not publicly accessible.
For photographs depicting human remains or burial sites, the archive explains that the photograph has been reviewed through community consultation and, in accordance with the guiding parameters developed by community participants, has restricted access with a content advisory and contextual information.
For photographs depicting altars, shrines or sacred sites, the archive explains that the photograph has been reviewed through community consultation and, in accordance with the guiding parameters developed by community participants, is highly restricted and is not publicly displayed. Researchers may request access through a written application.
These explanations make the access decision visible rather than presenting a restricted photograph simply as unavailable. They identify the relationship between the restriction and the community consultation process through which the parameters were developed.
A Living Framework
The photography archive is the result of a process that began with the recognition that colonial photographs require particular care when brought together in a digital environment.
The initial Approaching Colonial Photographs with Care document established the conceptual questions surrounding the collection: how photographs produced through colonial encounters should be understood, what it means to make them available again, and how digital access can reproduce earlier forms of looking and control (Odumosu 2024).
The subsequent workshops moved this discussion into a community-based process of evaluation. The review of 900 photographs with elders, chiefs, scholars and other knowledge holders in Benin City provided the basis for translating those questions into practical parameters for access.
The resulting framework does not attempt to resolve every question surrounding colonial photography. Instead, it establishes a set of principles and access conditions through which the archive can be approached with greater attention to cultural context, historical circumstances and the responsibilities involved in digital dissemination.
The archive therefore brings together two forms of work: the preservation and documentation of a dispersed photographic record, and the development of conditions under which that record can be encountered responsibly.
The more than 5,015 photographs now assembled through Digital Benin provide an important resource for researching the history of the Benin Kingdom, the 1897 invasion, colonial encounters and the subsequent circulation of Benin cultural heritage. At the same time, the access framework ensures that the value of these photographs as historical evidence is considered alongside the cultural knowledge and responsibilities that shape how they should be viewed and shared.
In this sense, Approaching Colonial Photographs with Care became not only a project about photographs, but also a process of reconsidering the relationship between archives, communities and digital access. The workshops, parameters and access levels developed through the project provide an enduring framework for engaging with the photography archive while recognising that responsible access depends on context, cultural authority and continued attention to the people and communities represented in the images.
Bibliography
Agassiz, Louis, and Elizabeth Cabot Cary Agassiz. A Journey in Brazil. Boston: Ticknor and Fields, 1869.
Azoulay, Ariella. The Civil Contract of Photography. Translated by Rela Mazali and Ruvik Danieli. New York: Zone Books, 2008.
Campt, Tina M. Listening to Images. Durham: Duke University Press, 2017.
Cole, Teju. Black Paper: Writing in a Dark Time. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2021.
Krabbe Meyer, Mette Kia, and Temi Odumosu, ‘One-Eyed Archive: Metadata Reflections on the USVI Photographic Collections at The Royal Danish Library’, Digital Culture & Society, 6.2 (2020), 35–62 https://doi.org/10.14361/dcs-2020-0204 (https://doi.org/10.14361/dcs-2020-0204).
Odumosu, Temi, ‘The Crying Child: On Colonial Archives, Digitization, and Ethics of Care in the Cultural Commons’, Current Anthropology, 61.S22 (2020), S289–S302 https://doi.org/10.1086/710062 (https://doi.org/10.1086/710062).
Odumosu, Temi. Approaching Colonial Photographs with Care. Digital Benin, 2024 https://website-b1x.pages.dev/documentation/approaching-colonial-photographs-with-care (https://website-b1x.pages.dev/documentation/approaching-colonial-photographs-with-care) [accessed 2 October 2026].
Staples, Amy J., et al. Fragile Legacies: The Photographs of Solomon Osagie Alonge. London: Giles, 2017.
Tayiana, Chao. Use of Derogatory, Racist and Harmful Language. Digital Benin, n.d.
Sensitive Content Digital Benin includes colonial material that may contain inaccurate, derogatory or harmful language relating to African and African diasporic communities. Such language may appear in catalogue records, transcriptions, and book, exhibition or museum titles. We recognize that this material may cause distress. Sensitive-content warnings are being implemented across the collection, but this process is ongoing. The language does not reflect Digital Benin’s views; we take an anti-colonial and anti-racist position and are committed to centring the humanity of historically marginalised communities.